Home » Blog » Variable frequency drive » Premature motor winding failures on VFD driven motors in high elevations
Premature motor winding failures on VFD driven motors in high elevations
Explaining some premature motor winding failures (multiple manufacturers) on VFD (multiple manufacturers) driven motors in high elevations. Some motors are VPI, all are inverter rated. Voltage varies from 460/480V - 575 and 690V. PWM varies from 1.5 - 3kHz. The failures are not seen at elevations below 3000M and the actual analysis of the failed motors are unreliable. Motors are appropriately derated for elevation in all cases.
As though the problem is universal across different manufacturers, the problem lies somewhere in the installation. This may due to the usual suspects of Voltage, Harmonics etc. As it pointed out, the problems do not appear below 3000m. Now this is a guess only as have not had experience in high altitude installations and someone more knowledgeable could confirm this, but when derating for these altitudes, need to apply a correction factor. In aviation, performance of an aircraft is 'normalised' by applying a temp factor over altitude. This accounts for the air density, less air, less lift and maybe less cooling in this application? For example at 2000 feet and a temp of 28 Celcius, gives the aircraft a performance equivalent to say 3500' or so. When manufacturers state a derating factor, we need to take this into account.
Not all Motor/VFD combinations have reactance in the output and it looks to be a plant wide phenomenon based on the description. De-rating already having been addressed tells us that these failed units are not failed due to thermal degradation. Since variable frequency drive connected motors are the only ones mentioned, assume the motor started with ATL and RVSS are not having high rates of failures. we would start at the plants transformer and meter the mains voltage, check plant ground.
Extreme altitude (4500m+) VFD applications required voltage derating to prevent corona at reduced atmospheric pressure - essentially, 575V rated VFDs operated at 380V, and motors wound with insulation suitable for 480V inverter duty (sea level).
As though the problem is universal across different manufacturers, the problem lies somewhere in the installation. This may due to the usual suspects of Voltage, Harmonics etc. As it pointed out, the problems do not appear below 3000m. Now this is a guess only as have not had experience in high altitude installations and someone more knowledgeable could confirm this, but when derating for these altitudes, need to apply a correction factor. In aviation, performance of an aircraft is 'normalised' by applying a temp factor over altitude. This accounts for the air density, less air, less lift and maybe less cooling in this application? For example at 2000 feet and a temp of 28 Celcius, gives the aircraft a performance equivalent to say 3500' or so. When manufacturers state a derating factor, we need to take this into account.
Not all Motor/VFD combinations have reactance in the output and it looks to be a plant wide phenomenon based on the description. De-rating already having been addressed tells us that these failed units are not failed due to thermal degradation. Since variable frequency drive connected motors are the only ones mentioned, assume the motor started with ATL and RVSS are not having high rates of failures. we would start at the plants transformer and meter the mains voltage, check plant ground.
Extreme altitude (4500m+) VFD applications required voltage derating to prevent corona at reduced atmospheric pressure - essentially, 575V rated VFDs operated at 380V, and motors wound with insulation suitable for 480V inverter duty (sea level).
The motor power factor does not make a big difference other than giving an idea of loading. In regards to the variable speed drive fixing power factor everyone is mostly correct. A variable speed drive will ...
Due to current decrement in the Generator during fault conditions the Back-up protection with IDMT relay for a generator in the Electrical protection Scheme becomes complicated. Accordingly, the setting of the ...
If a guarantee is involved with stiff liquidated damages, then lots of testing and certification on each serial numbered unit is likely to be necessary. (not to mention the cost of law suits....). Like the ...
1. Slip energy recovery with the current motor but with dual inverter on rotor side, which may not be too expensive as it is lower power on rotor side and no change in motor.
2. Slip ring motor with shorted ...
Converting a synchronous motor to an induction motor is easily done, to most motors, by shorting the rings, however, you would most likely need to use a properly sized VFD to get the starting torque you need. ...
VSD blog: A deep observation of automation control industry, especially in AC motor variable speed drive for industrial motor controls.
7 months back I was involved in a harmonics evaluation study at Budweiser. This was one of many I've participated in over the past 20 years, basically because in facilities like ...
Most of variable speed drives are applying on high temperature fans, kiln head coal mill fans, kiln head surplus fans, raw mill circulating fans and so on. Two production lines ...
Variable speed drive application in purification system optimizes the system performance, improves purification effect, reduces power consumption greatly. According to related ...
The motor power factor does not make a big difference other than giving an idea of loading. In regards to the variable speed drive fixing power factor everyone is mostly correct. ...
A soft starter is a basic device which will ramp up the speed of your motor to full speed over a preset time, easing mechanical stress and also easing the high inrush currents ...
Variable Speed Drive Harmonics
Variable speed drive energy saving in cement industry
PLC and DAQ
Is it good to do preventive maintenance for variable speed drives
Does motor starts number affect motor life?
Variable speed drive for ID Fans in mining industry
Regenerative power frequency back to line power
Variable speed drive for axial-flow fans
Variable speed drive energy saving in cement industry
PLC and DAQ
Is it good to do preventive maintenance for variable speed drives
Does motor starts number affect motor life?
Variable speed drive for ID Fans in mining industry
Regenerative power frequency back to line power
Variable speed drive for axial-flow fans